Flying taxis always sounded like one of those futuristic ideas that looked good in articles, movies and concept videos but never quite arrived in real life. This week, that future came a little closer.

Joby Aviation, which we covered before, began a series of piloted electric air taxi demonstration flights in New York, flying between John F. Kennedy International Airport and several Manhattan heliports. The flights used real airport and city infrastructure, not a closed test site, which makes this more than just another tech demo.

To be clear, this is not a passenger service yet. You cannot open an app and book a flying taxi from JFK to Manhattan today. Joby still needs regulatory approval before it can carry paying passengers in the U.S. But the New York flights are an important signal: flying taxis are moving from science-fiction promise to real-world urban testing.

The appeal is easy to understand. Anyone who has landed at a major airport knows the frustration of the final trip into town. The flight may be over, but then comes the traffic, the tunnel, the surge pricing, or the unpredictable ride that can turn a short distance into a long delay. Joby has said a future JFK-to-Manhattan trip could take only minutes, compared with a much longer car ride in traffic. As a heavy traveler, I like this!

But the bigger question is not just whether flying taxis could help some travelers skip congestion. It is what everyone else will have to live with.

If electric air taxis become part of city life, most people may never ride in one. But they may still hear them. They may see them flying over buildings, parks, schools, neighborhoods, and homes. That changes the conversation from convenience to public acceptance.

Would people feel safe with a new category of aircraft flying regularly over dense cities? Would the aircraft be quiet enough for residents to tolerate? Would cities welcome more activity in the sky if only a small number of people can afford to use the service?

That is where this story becomes more emotional than technical. With the technology aspect soon to be solved, the simple question for everyone living under the flight paths is: who gets the benefit, and who gets the disruption?

For now, Joby’s New York campaign is still a demonstration, not the beginning of everyday flying taxi service. But it makes the future feel closer and more realistic than before.

would you be okay with them flying over your house?

Filed in . Read more about Flying Car and Taxi.