I think it’s safe to assume we’ve all heard of golden retriever boyfriends by now. And perhaps you’re also familiar with the GRBF’s dark, moody foil, the black cat boyfriend? Well, meet his female counterpart: the black cat girlfriend.

As you might expect, the black cat girlfriend is essentially what she sounds like: “A partner who mirrors the classic personality traits we often associate with black cats, mysterious, independent, and selectively affectionate,” explains relationship coach Amie Leadingham. “A black cat girlfriend is highly selective about where they invest their social energy, values their alone time, tends to be more introverted, and has a slightly aloof yet intimidating quality about them that draws people in.”

But don’t let the seemingly standoffish vibes fool you. There’s much more to the black cat girlfriend archetype than her withdrawn, slightly witchy exterior lets on (and that’s part of her magic). Embedded within the black cat’s cool, seemingly detached personality is the potential for true devotion and vulnerability—with the right person, of course. Once you’ve earned their trust, “they become fiercely loyal and affectionate,” says Leadingham.

Below, dating experts weigh in on everything you need to know about black cat girlfriends, from what it really means to be one to whether black cat girlfriends and golden retriever boyfriends are actually compatible.

What Is Like to Date a Black Cat Girlfriend?

“A black cat girlfriend is the walking embodiment of ‘I’m good either way’ energy,” says Sabrina Bendory, a relationship coach for Dating.com and author of the forthcoming book Detached: How to Let Go, Heal, and Become Irresistible. “She’s independent, confident, and just a little mysterious. Think: ‘I have my own life, but you’re welcome to orbit it.’”

The female counterpart of (and in many ways the antithesis to) the golden retriever boyfriend—the endlessly doing partner who lives to adore and be adored—the black cat girlfriend is more reserved, self-sufficient, and, crucially, more selective. While the golden retriever boyfriend may be characterized as “just happy to be there,” Bendory explains, black cat girlfriends choose to be there. “And when we do, it’s because we genuinely want you, not because we’re trying to fill a void,” Bendory adds.

A golden retriever boyfriend, by comparison, “is stereotypically social, confident, friendly, warm, outgoing and eager to please,” adds relationship coach and psychotherapist Samantha Burns. “Whereas someone who is a black cat may be a bit more cautious and wary of giving their love and attention freely. With a black cat girlfriend you have to initially ‘earn it,’ but once you prove yourself, they are loving and affectionate.”

Is Being a Black Cat Girlfriend a Bad Thing?

It’s easy to mistake black cat girlfriend energy as cold, avoidant, or even “pick-me”–coded, hence why some might interpret the BCGF label as negative. But the thing that makes the black cat girlfriend so compelling is that she’s not any of those things. Her confidence and independence come from a place of authenticity, not fear or performance.

“It’s the opposite of performing for male approval; she’s magnetic because she’s good on her own,” Bendory explains. “She’s not trying to be the ‘cool girl’ in order to get the guy, she just is who she is—and there is nothing sexier than that.”

And while many may mistake the black cat’s independent, slow-to-warm approach to relationships for fear-based avoidance, Bendory says the true black cat girlfriend “isn’t afraid to be vulnerable, be present, and actually connect” with the right person.

“Being a black cat girlfriend is actually a sign of emotional maturity and strong boundaries,” adds Leadingham. “They know their worth, and they’re not going to give their energy away to just anyone.”

Far from the cold, calculating femme fatales black cats are sometimes made out to be, a black cat mentality is actually “one of the most powerful dating mindsets you can have,” says Bendory. “A black cat doesn’t chase, she attracts. If she’s giving you her time, it’s because she wants to, not because she’s trying to prove something.”

Moreover, all the experts I spoke to for this story agree that BCGF energy can actually be an incredibly healthy and rewarding thing to bring to a relationship.

Are Black Cat Girlfriends and Golden Retriever Boyfriends Compatible?

Social media wisdom commonly holds that “every relationship has a golden retriever boyfriend and a black cat girlfriend.” And while we’re told opposites attract, is golden retriever energy really a match for your typical black cat?

In short, it can be!

“They can be a great match—as long as both are coming from a healthy place. If the black cat is just dissociating and afraid to be vulnerable, that’s not mysterious—that’s avoidance,” says Bendory. “And if the golden retriever is insecure, desperate, and willing to be her loyal servant no matter how she treats him, that’s not devotion—that’s a doormat.”

Basically, black cat on golden retriever compatibility all depends on whether both parties are able to “understand and appreciate their differences rather than trying to change each other,” says Leadingham.

If they can do that, then black cats and golden retrievers may even be able to learn from each other and establish a kind of ying-yang harmony in a relationship. “I like to say that golden retriever boyfriends have a secure attachment style, which means they are comfortable with closeness and intimacy, they communicate well, they are reliable, and confident in expressing their feelings,“ says Burns. “A black cat girlfriend may be a bit more reserved, skeptical, or slower to warm up initially. But once that connection is created they also model this security, confidence, affection, and loyalty towards their partner.”

Ultimately, whether or not a golden retriever is the right partner for you as the prospective black cat girlfriend is up to you to decide. Because, as Burns notes, the most defining feature of the BCGF is that she “is comfortable with her independence and is proactive in getting her needs met. She knows what she wants and doesn’t feel the need to constantly be on or people please.”