West Wilson just showed up on The Broadcast Boys and revealed more information about his secret relationship with Amanda Batula than he did throughout the entire three-part Summer House reunion—including about their much-discussed timeline. And apparently Lindsay Hubbard isn’t having it.

During his chat, West stuck to his previous claim that nothing happened between him and Amanda until LATE February (and that they were NOT together during the Super Bowl in early February). But he also said that they’d been making out for a long time before having sex post-statement. As he put it, “We fucked after the statement statement but we’d been making out and having sleep overs for a long time.”

Cut to Lindsay, who wrote on Threads, “I’m confused about how they previously said that nothing happened until the ‘end of Feb’ but their statement came out on March 31st (so that’s only 1 month later)… but then on the white boards WW said they had been making out and having sleepovers for ‘a longgg time’ prior to their statement. So what is a ‘long time’ then? I’m assuming for WW to consider something ‘a long time’ that’s gotta be longer than 1 month. Just sayin: the timeline still isn’t adding up, and the pathy is back at it.”

West was pretty insistent that he and Amanda were strictly friends until she was officially single, but honestly only one thing will clear this up: a Jesse Solomon-style timeline with date stamps.