Looks like those rumors about Love on the Spectrum couple Abbey Romeo and David Isaacman are more than likely true. To catch everyone up real fast, these two were one of the original love stories on the beloved Netflix reality show, but fans have been concerned about a secret breakup for a few months. Mostly because Abbey and David stopped posting each other on social media—even skipping Valentine’s Day, which was a first.

However, chatter calmed down a few weeks ago in March, when Abbey went on the We Need to Talk podcast and talked about David as if he was very much still in her life. “David and I like to go places, like the L.A. Zoo, Disneyland, Universal Studios, the Griffith Observatory,” she said. “He says things that make me feel good [and] he covers my ears when there’s a certain noise I don’t like.”

But multiple outlets now report that the pair have split. A source tells The Sun, “Sadly it’s true that David and Abbey broke up. They couldn’t come to an agreement on when to get married. She was ready years ago, he still needed time.”

An insider close to David added that “They did break up, but he is doing very well.”

Abbey and David fell for each other during Season 1 of Love on the Spectrum, and were together for almost five years.