West Wilson and Amanda Batula’s timeline is extremely iffy at this point, but it looks like they’re sticking to the story that they didn’t start dating until February. Which raises a lot of questions for their fellow Summer House stars, including Bailey, who wants to know why Amanda was kissing her estranged husband Kyle Cooke—who she was separated from at the time—on February 28.

Bailey went on Watch What Happens Live last night with Lindsay Hubbard, and said, “Amanda was grabbing Kyle’s face and really heavily kissing him. February 28. I know now because of Jesse Solomon. I said to West, ‘What are they doing?’ and he said ‘Let them do their thing.’ Now I’m like, why did he say that?”

Meanwhile, Lindsay chimed in with, “Imagine using your husband as a decoy for your boyfriend.”

West previously tried to clear up his and Amanda’s timeline during the Show Me Something podcast, saying, “We realized things were maybe a little bit serious in February and that’s when this all started, and there’s not a whole lot more to it than that.”

As for whether or not Lindsay is in touch with West and Amanda post-reunion, she told Andy We filmed the reunion on Thursday, Amanda texted me on Friday, I responded saying, ‘I’m on my way to Stagecoach,’ and then West texted me on Sunday night, also still at Stagecoach, and I just haven’t responded to him. It’s going to take time for me to respond to him.”

Lindsay confirmed that she’d grown close to Amanda while filming In the City, noting, “I had Amanda’s back. This whole situation has disappointed me a lot.” When it comes to hanging out now, Lindsay said, “I’m a little busy” and “we’ll see.”