Ben Stokes has defended England’s decision to excuse Jofra Archer from the start of the Test summer so he could compete in the Indian Premier League, saying a more militant approach risks a situation where “players like him might not play for England again”.

On Wednesday Archer was strongly criticised by the former New Zealand bowler Simon Doull, who described his absence as “absolutely ludicrous” and “completely wrong”. The former England batter Mark Butcher has previously said it was “absolutely ridiculous”, while Michael Atherton described it as “incredibly frustrating”.

But while Stokes admitted he “totally understands people’s frustrations around the situation”, particularly given that Archer is tied to an ECB central contract which runs until 2027 and in theory allows the England setup to determine his schedule, he also suggested its most high-profile critics were stuck in the past.

“There’s another side to it, and a lot of it’s got to do with the landscape of cricket and where it is at the moment,” England’s Test captain said. “I think a lot of the points that people have been making around Jof and that situation are to do with the landscape when they were playing. But it’s completely different now. There’s opportunities for cricketers now that there wasn’t 10, 15, 20 years ago.

“Yes, in an ideal situation it would be unbelievably great to have everyone you want available at every single opportunity. That is not the way of cricket at the moment. There is so much more out there for players. There are other opportunities and you want players to be able to do them, and also to play for England.

“There is a situation where it could get messy and players like Jofra might not play for England again if you handle it in a different way, and that is not good for anyone. Jofra has shown that he’s committed and loves playing for England. Just because he’s not available for this first Test match does not change that.”

Archer has just completed his most successful IPL season, taking 25 wickets for Rajasthan Royals as they reached the playoffs, putting him third in this year’s bowling rankings. He played his last game on Friday, before flying to Barbados for what Brendon McCullum, the England coach, described as “a little bit of a break”. He is expected to play some part in the Test series against New Zealand but will not be at Lord’s when the first Test starts on Thursday, and it is not yet known whether he will be available for the second game, which begins at the Oval on 17 June.

“It’s ludicrous, absolutely ludicrous,” Doull told Sky. “How are you paying this guy up to £1m a year and he’s not available for your first Test match? There’s no reason that Jofra Archer couldn’t have been bowling six or seven overs [with the red ball] in between [games]. The fact that he is not doing that tells me he has no interest in playing Test cricket. And why are the ECB not then having discussions with the [Royals] team, saying: ‘We need him to be ready for Test match cricket’? I think it’s completely wrong.”

Stokes admitted that his team had developed a habit of “consistently letting ourselves down” at crunch moments in Test matches, a trend which their much-trailed reset is intended to address.

“It’s not a massive change, to be honest,” he said. “As much as people want to hear us say that, it’s not. It’s being a lot smarter in those big moments in games, because I will admit that consistently when [they] were in the balance, when it was neither one way nor the other, we let ourselves down. The decisions we thought were the right ones to make let the opposition get ahead of us. Especially over the past 18 months we’ve contributed towards losing games of cricket on too much of a consistent basis.”