We study the number of local maxima with given radial derivative of spherical mixed $p$-spin models and prove that the second moment matches the square of the first moment on exponential scale for arbitrary mixtures and any radial derivative. This is surprising, since for the number of local maxima with given radial derivative and given energy the corresponding result is only true for specific mixtures [Sub17; BSZ20]. We use standard Kac-Rice computations to derive formulas for the first and second moment at exponential scale, and then find a remarkable analytic argument that shows that the second moment formula is bounded by twice the first moment formula in this general setting. This also leads to a new proof of a central inequality used to prove concentration of the number critical points of pure $p$-spin models of given energy in [Sub17] and removes the need for the computer assisted argument used in that paper for $3 \leq p \leq 10$.