The (strong) Bruhat order for permutations provides a partial ordering defined as follows: two permutations are comparable if one can be obtained from the other by a sequence of adjacent transpositions that each increase the number of inversions by $1$. Given two random permutations, what is the probability that they are comparable in the Bruhat order? This problem was first considered in a 2006 work of Hammett and Pittel, which showed an exponential lower bound and a polynomial upper bound. The lower bound was very recently improved to the subexponential bound of $\exp(-n^{1/2 + o(1)})$ by Boretsky, Cornejo, Hodges, Horn, Lesnevich, and McAllister. Hammett and Pittel predicted that the probability should decrease polynomially. We show that the probability decreases faster than any polynomial and is on the order of $\exp(-Θ(\log^2 n))$.