In this work, we study the Induced Matching problem: Given an undirected graph $G$ and an integer $\ell$, is there an induced matching $M$ of size at least $\ell$? An edge subset $M$ is an induced matching in $G$ if $M$ is a matching such that there is no edge between two distinct edges of $M$. Our work looks into the parameterized complexity of Induced Matching with respect to "below guarantee" parameterizations. We consider the parameterization $u - \ell$ for an upper bound $u$ on the size of any induced matching. For instance, any induced matching is of size at most $n / 2$ where $n$ is the number of vertices, which gives us a parameter $n / 2 - \ell$. In fact, there is a straightforward $9^{n/2 - \ell} \cdot n^{O(1)}$-time algorithm for Induced Matching [Moser and Thilikos, J. Discrete Algorithms]. Motivated by this, we ask: Is Induced Matching FPT for a parameter smaller than $n / 2 - \ell$? In search for such parameters, we consider $MM(G) - \ell$ and $IS(G) - \ell$, where $MM(G)$ is the maximum matching size and $IS(G)$ is the maximum independent set size of $G$. We find that Induced Matching is presumably not FPT when parameterized by $MM(G) - \ell$ or $IS(G) - \ell$. In contrast to these intractability results, we find that taking the average of the two helps -- our main result is a branching algorithm that solves Induced Matching in $49^{(MM(G) + IS(G))/ 2 - \ell} \cdot n^{O(1)}$ time. Our algorithm makes use of the Gallai-Edmonds decomposition to find a structure to branch on.