Autoregressive inference is typically assumed to scale predictably with decoding length, with latency increasing smoothly as generated sequence length grows. In this work, we identify unexpected non-monotonic latency behavior in the Apple MPS backend, where latency changes abruptly across nearby decoding configurations during transformer decoding. Using multiple model families (GPT-2, BLOOM, and OPT), we observe latency spikes of up to 21x within specific decoding-budget intervals, followed by recovery at neighboring configurations. Controlled experiments show that these anomalies originate primarily during the decode phase rather than prefill, are not explained by memory pressure alone, and remain absent on CPU and NVIDIA CUDA backends under identical conditions. We further show that key-value (KV) cache interacts strongly with these pathological execution regimes: KV caching remains beneficial overall, but its practical speedup collapses sharply within anomalous configurations, while cache-disabled decoding still exhibits residual non-monotonic behavior. These findings suggest that autoregressive decoding on MPS enters discrete execution regimes that are not captured by coarse-grained benchmarking, highlighting the importance of hardware-aware evaluation for long-context inference.