After they were reportedly hanging out several times in Brooklyn last week, the internet has started theorizing that Joe Alwyn and Sarah Pidgeon may be an item. The Love Story star and Hamnet actor sparked dating rumors on June 13 after a DeuxMoi source spotted them at Roman’s in Fort Greene and claimed they “shared a lengthy three-hour dinner.”

The insider added that the actors “lingered long after most diners would have called it a night,” largely because of the rain that took over the city on Saturday night. They added that Sarah and Joe apparently waited out the storm on a nearby stoop before they went back inside and kept their dinner going.

A day later, on Sunday, June 14, they were photographed strolling through the same Brooklyn neighborhood, per a separate DeuxMoi tip. A new report from People also claims that the pair shared a kiss during their second outing together.

While neither of the actors has commented on the nature of their relationship just yet, it’s important to note that both Joe and Sarah are pretty private when it comes to their love lives.

Joe famously dated Taylor Swift and kept much of their relationship away from the spotlight for six years before they called it quits in April 2023. Sarah has remained tight-lipped about her dating life, but was rumored to be dating Spacey Jane frontman Caleb Harper earlier this year.

Whether these two are dating or not remains a mystery, but for now…the clues seem to be clue-ing!