The jury is still out on whether a Pisces and a Gemini can, in fact, go really nice together…but I do know this: Notoriously spicy Pisces Olivia Rodrigo has dated a total of five men in her life and three of them are Geminis. And naturally, ever since this info was revealed, fans have been trying to figure out the five lucky guys to whom Liv could be alluding.

During her Cosmo cover story, the pop star casually let it slip to her bestie Madison Hu that “three of the five guys I’ve dated in my life have been Geminis.” Which is particularly interesting, given that she was most recently linked to known Gemini Louis Partridge (born June 3), who may or may not have inspired the “drop dead” lyric, “Pisces and a Gemini / But I think we might go really nice together.”

So…if Louis is one of the three Geminis Liv has romanced, then who are the other two? Also, who are the two non-Geminis in Olivia’s dating history?

Before Louis, Liv was linked to Zack Bia back in 2022. According to a source for E! News, “He invited her to Super Bowl parties that he was DJing that weekend and she went to support him. They hit it off and have been casually hanging out.”

The relationship was short-lived, fizzling out in August of that year, with a source telling Us Weekly that “they both have different work schedules and different friend groups.” However! Zack’s birthday is June 9, so Liv likely counts him as one of her Gemini exes.

Also (probably) on the list: Adam Faze, who Liv began dating in summer 2021 before a People source claimed in February 2022, “They’ve been over for a bit now.” Adam was born on May 28, so…feels safe to assume he also counts!

So…what about those two non-Geminis on Olivia’s list? My best guess is that she’s referring to Joshua Bassett (who was born on December 22, making him a Capricorn) and Ethan Wacker, whose birthday falls on May 8 (which makes him a Taurus).

But that’s just my guess, so take all this ^^^ with a grain of salt!