Yes, repurposing multiple-choice question-answering (MCQA) models for document reranking is both feasible and valuable. This preliminary work is founded on mathematical parallels between MCQA decision-making and cross-encoder semantic relevance assessments, leading to the development of R*, a proof-of-concept model that harmonizes these approaches. Designed to assess document relevance with depth and precision, R* showcases how MCQA's principles can improve reranking in information retrieval (IR) and retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) systems -- ultimately enhancing search and dialogue in AI-powered systems. Through experimental validation, R* proves to improve retrieval accuracy and contribute to the field's advancement by demonstrating a practical prototype of MCQA for reranking by keeping it lightweight.