Commercial buildings account for approximately 35% of total US electricity consumption, of which nearly two-thirds is met by fossil fuels resulting in an adverse impact on the environment. This adverse impact can be mitigated by lowering energy consumption via control of occupant plugload usage in a closed-loop building environment. In this work, we conducted multiple experiments to analyze changes in occupant plugload energy consumption due to incentives and/or visual feedback. The incentives entailed daily monetary values between $5 and $50 administered in a randomized order and the visual feedback consisted of a web-based dashboard aimed at increasing the energy awareness of participants. Experiments were performed in government office and university buildings at NASA Ames Research Park located in Moffett Field, CA. Autoregressive models were constructed to predict expected plugload savings in the presence of exogenous variables. Analysis of the data revealed modulation of plugload energy consumption can be achieved via visual feedback and incentive mechanisms suggesting that occupant-in-the-loop control architectures may be effective in the commercial building environment. Our findings indicate that the mean energy reduction due to visual feedback in office and university environments were ~9.52% and ~21.61%, respectively. By augmenting the visual feedback in the university environment with a monetary incentive, the mean energy reduction was found to be ~24.22%