惯性聚合 高效追踪和阅读你感兴趣的博客、新闻、科技资讯
阅读原文 在惯性聚合中打开

推荐订阅源

Recent Announcements
Recent Announcements
freeCodeCamp Programming Tutorials: Python, JavaScript, Git & More
Last Week in AI
Last Week in AI
Scott Helme
Scott Helme
cs.AI updates on arXiv.org
cs.AI updates on arXiv.org
L
LINUX DO - 最新话题
S
Security @ Cisco Blogs
Webroot Blog
Webroot Blog
S
Security Affairs
H
Hacker News: Front Page
TaoSecurity Blog
TaoSecurity Blog
W
WeLiveSecurity
G
GRAHAM CLULEY
T
Tenable Blog
Schneier on Security
Schneier on Security
S
Securelist
Cyberwarzone
Cyberwarzone
P
Privacy International News Feed
Exploit-DB.com RSS Feed
Exploit-DB.com RSS Feed
S
Schneier on Security
Hacker News - Newest:
Hacker News - Newest: "LLM"
Recent Commits to openclaw:main
Recent Commits to openclaw:main
O
OpenAI News
N
News and Events Feed by Topic
AWS News Blog
AWS News Blog
C
Cisco Blogs
T
Threat Research - Cisco Blogs
S
Secure Thoughts
大猫的无限游戏
大猫的无限游戏
C
Check Point Blog
The GitHub Blog
The GitHub Blog
G
Google Developers Blog
奇客Solidot–传递最新科技情报
奇客Solidot–传递最新科技情报
美团技术团队
Martin Fowler
Martin Fowler
Microsoft Security Blog
Microsoft Security Blog
L
LangChain Blog
Apple Machine Learning Research
Apple Machine Learning Research
爱范儿
爱范儿
D
DataBreaches.Net
博客园_首页
MyScale Blog
MyScale Blog
博客园 - 叶小钗
博客园 - 三生石上(FineUI控件)
P
Proofpoint News Feed
J
Java Code Geeks
SecWiki News
SecWiki News
P
Palo Alto Networks Blog
Know Your Adversary
Know Your Adversary
cs.CL updates on arXiv.org
cs.CL updates on arXiv.org

Latest Issue | Current Issue - Frontline Magazine | Frontline

Exploring the Intersections of Identity, Geopolitics, and Mental Health in New Indian Publishing Notes from Ginza Shihodo Shop: A Quietly Healing Read Migrant crisis to war shock: India’s fragile safety nets India Hit by Hormuz Crisis as Iran War Sends Oil Prices Soaring Why the Iran War and Internal Contradictions Signal the End of Dollar Hegemony West Asia Volatility and India’s Economic Vulnerability Amidst Domestic Political Rhetoric The Great Nicobar Project: Documenting the Costs of "Haste Dressed Up as Vision" Beyond Statist Tropes: How Kinship and Trade Redefine the Himalayan Borderlands Defining Modern Hinduism: Rajmohan Gandhi on the Shift from Ethic to Identity Inside ODI Art Centre: Preserving Odisha’s living heritage Noida Unrest and the Reality of India’s Workers Intercaste Marriage Violence in India: Who Protects Women? How the Supreme Court hardened UAPA bail rules in Delhi riots case BJP’s Women’s Reservation Push Faces Opposition Revolt Purvanchal Emerges as Key Battleground for UP Election 2027 Ketaki Sheth’s Flashback: Rare Glimpses of Film Sets Tulika at 30: Radhika Menon on Children’s Books in India Can the Stage Contain Theyyam’s Wildness? This Is Where the Serpent Lives: Power, class, and desire NCR Worker Protests: Low Wages, State Crackdown Gaza Genocide Blueprint: B’Tselem’s Yair Dvir Speaks Will Didi prevail over Delhi? Punishing the South: Modi’s Delimitation Plan and the Politics of Control India Census 2027: Who Gets Counted—and How? SIR West Bengal Voter Exclusion Case 2026 Healthcare’s Breaking Point India’s Elderly Boom: Care Gaps and Policy Failures AI chatbots fill mental health gaps in India, but risks grow Substandard Drugs in India: The Hidden Public Health Threat India Healthcare Costs Crisis: Who Pays the Price? ASHAs hold India’s fragile health system together but are woefully underpaid Occupational Health Crisis in India: Silicosis and Beyond Techno-Elitism vs. Universal Care: The Growing Access Gap in India’s Health Revolution India’s Health System: The Broken Promise of Primary Care Partha Chatterjee’s For a Just Republic and the Limits of the People-Nation Why Jerry Pinto’s 'A Good Life' is Essential Reading for India’s Evolving Healthcare System Ambedkar Caste Critique: Justice Beyond Reform India’s Missing Middle: Trapped Between Health Insurance and Care Hungary Election 2026: Orbán Defeated, Magyar Wins Big Sewage, Neglect, and Governance Failure Mark India's Water Crisis The Hidden Ecosystem Inside our Homes Women’s Health in India: Inequality by Design Absolute Jafar: Nostalgia and restlessness in frames Anita Nair’s Why I Killed My Husband Review: Powerful Themes, Uneven Storytelling Iran War Ceasefire Signals a Shift Toward Multipolar Deterrence How Deepti Priya Mehrotra’s Walking Out, Speaking Up Recovers the Radical History of Indian Feminist Agitprop Lalit’s Lyrical Shift Writing New History China’s rise tests US power but avoids global confrontation Why The Dig Fails to Unearth the Material Reality of Keeladi Archaeology Ferdino Rebello on Goa land protests, TCP Act, and casino politics John Irving on Queen Esther, Politics, and the Writing Process Inside the Studios of Contemporary Indian Artists Hind Rajab and the Limits of Representation in Cinema How Muslims and Tea Tribes may Decide Assam Elections Tamil Nadu Election 2026: How Gender and Gen Z Voters are Reshaping the Dravidian Power Struggle Inside BJP’s Strategy to Win Puducherry Assembly Flesh Review: A stark, experimental Booker winner LDF, UDF, BJP Rework Kerala Campaigns Amid Gulf Crisis Assam election 2026: Polarisation shapes BJP vs Congress fight Tamil Nadu 2026 Elections: New Forces and Voter Trends West Bengal election arithmetic favours Trinamool, says Biswanath Chakraborty Electoral Roll Purge and Political Polarisation Shape Bengal’s High-Stakes Election Kerala Election: LDF, UDF in Tight Battle Lakshadweep Land Acquisition 2026: Constitutional Concerns and Tribal Displacement on Agatti Island Gurmeet Ram Rahim Acquitted in Ram Chandra Chhatrapati Murder Case, Questions Persist US-Israel Iran war: how religion and politics are colliding Trump Iran War Fallout: Strategy Unravels Fast Moral Collapse and the Crisis of Justice UP’s ‘Half Encounter’ Policing Faces Sharp Judicial Rebuke Women of Mathematics Exhibition 2026: Rewriting Science’s Gender Gap Pop History meets Romila Thapar: A Review of Speaking of History From Kerosene Lamps to Electric Lights in Palluruthy Gen Z Wave Propels Balen Shah and RSP to Power in Nepal Chipko Movement and Power of Nonviolent Resistance Right to Recall: Accountability Tool or Political Risk? Mani Shankar Aiyar Attacks Tharoor’s Stand on US Power and Iran War India Poverty Rate Debate 2026: 5% or 24%? Beyond Global Islam: Faisal Devji on the Crisis of Modern Muslim Sovereignty and the Fall of Khamenei The Paradox of Preservation: Why India’s Ajanta Caves Face a 50-Year Countdown to Disappearance Inside Kochi-Muziris Biennale 2025: Art in the Everyday Tamil Nadu 2026: Can Vijay and Seeman Challenge Dravidian Politics? Iran–Israel War Escalates, Shaking Security Across the Gulf George Saunders’ Vigil: A Dark Meditation on Death Why Amitav Ghosh’s Ghost-Eye Fails to Convince How Iran’s Shi'ite Ideology Shapes its War with the US and Israel A French 'grandmother' brings alive the early days of Santiniketan INDIA Bloc Leadership Debate Puts Rahul Gandhi Under Spotlight Iran War 2026: US Strategy and Global South Crisis Called by the Hills: Anuradha Roy’s Himalayan memoir Governor’s Office Reform: Tamil Nadu Panel Seeks Federal Reset How the US–Israel War on Iran Defied International Law India, Israel and Iran: The Tightrope After Modi’s Trip Rafale Expansion vs Tejas Setback: India’s Air Power Crossroads How Sankar reshaped Calcutta in popular fiction R. Nallakannu Dies at 101: CPI’s Resistant Voice How the Absence of Shame is Reshaping Indian Democracy M.K. Stalin Can Unite Opposition Against Hindutva Meghalaya Rat-Hole Mining: A Deadly Economy in Plain Sight Kumar Shahani: Visionary filmmaker who pushed Indian cinema’s boundaries
Holding Centres Spark a New Bangladeshi Exodus from Bengal
Suhrid Sankar Chattopadhyay · 2026-06-02 · via Latest Issue | Current Issue - Frontline Magazine | Frontline

For the second time in just seven months, West Bengal is witnessing a mass exodus of Bangladeshis who have been living in India after having crossed the border illegally. The first flight of the illegal immigrants took place in November 2025, when the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls was announced in West Bengal, months ahead of the Assembly election.

The latest rush to the border was precipitated by the newly elected BJP government’s announcement of the establishment of “holding centres” across the State to house undocumented migrants pending deportation. Staying true to its election promise to “detect, delete, and deport” illegal Bangladeshi immigrants, the West Bengal government on May 23—just two weeks after being sworn in—issued an order to set up holding centres in all 23 districts for “apprehended foreigners as well as for the released foreign prisoners awaiting deportation/repatriation in accordance with the MHA [Ministry of Home Affairs] guidelines”.

The first two holding centres were set up on May 24 in the Muslim-majority districts of Malda and Murshidabad that share a border with Bangladesh; and nine more have been established in less than a week. According to reports, as of May 29, more than 380 Bangladeshi nationals were housed in these centres. They are being allowed to enter Bangladesh after their national identity has been verified.

While the BJP’s ascent to power in the State had caused unease among Bangladeshis who stayed back through the SIR exercise, the announcement of the “holding centres” sent them into a panic. Numbers began to swell rapidly at the Hakimpur checkpost in the Bengal-Bangladesh border in North 24 Parganas. Indigent settlers, who had come to India in the hope of a better life, left their homes and dreams behind in a hurry, carrying with them only the most necessary items, including their Bangladeshi citizenship papers.

Driven by extreme poverty, practically all of them had crossed over to India in the hope of earning a living. Some were living here for a few years, others for decades. Life was hardly a bed of roses in India, where they could only eke out a living as labourers, cleaners, and domestic helpers, yet they believed it was better than what they would be go back to in their own country. Most of them have paid large amounts—as much as Rs.20,000 or even Rs.30,000—to middlemen to get across the border.

While some illegal immigrants maintain that they never had any Indian identity card like Aadhaar or PAN, did not benefit from government welfare schemes, and did not vote, there are others who admit that they had all the necessary documents required for an Indian citizen and even voted in past elections.

At the Hakimpur border, Mafuza Khatoun was waiting for her documents to be vetted so that she could cross the border into Bangladesh. She said she had spent most of her life in West Bengal though she was originally from Khulna district in Bangladesh. “I have Aadhaar card, ration card, all the documents required in this country... I was getting Lakshmir Bhandar [the monthly allowance of Rs.1,500 that the Trinamool Congress government gave to women from economically backward backgrounds] until recently, and all the benefits and welfare schemes that were available; I voted three times in the elections here.”

Life was not easy in India for illegal immigrants from Bangladesh. Yet they had preferred the challenges in their adopted country over the uncertainties back home. Here, waiting at Hakimpur to be allowed to cross back into Bangladesh.

Life was not easy in India for illegal immigrants from Bangladesh. Yet they had preferred the challenges in their adopted country over the uncertainties back home. Here, waiting at Hakimpur to be allowed to cross back into Bangladesh. | Photo Credit: JAYANTA SHAW

She claimed her children were born in West Bengal and studied in government schools. Mafuza, like many other illegal immigrants, claimed that all her documents were provided by local Trinamool Congress members.

Ali Munshi said that Trinamool workers in his neighbourhood told him and his father that they would provide them with all the documents. In return, they would be expected to vote for the Trinamool. “They [Trinamool workers] said, since you are now one of us, we will look after you, and you will have to vote for us. Now that the government has changed and the BJP has come, we are afraid. So, instead of living in fear, we decided to go back to Bangladesh,” said Ali.

Discomfiture for Trinamool Congress

Most agreed that they would not have to leave if the Trinamool remained in power. “The new BJP government has made it clear that there is no place for us here. Things would have been different if the old Trinamool government was in power; we would not have to leave everything and go,” said a Bangladeshi who had been living in Kolkata for the past six years.

The claims of some of these migrants that they were helped by the previous Trinamool regime has served to strengthen the BJP’s allegation that former Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee and her party were using illegal immigrants as a captive “vote bank”.

An oft-repeated election promise of the BJP was that, if it came to power, it would identify and apprehend illegal immigrants and “Rohingyas” from Bangladesh and deport them. One of the first decisions of the new government was to begin a State-wide crackdown on illegal immigrants.

“Run quickly, or the government will do what needs to be done,” was Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari’s warning to Bangladeshi settlers. “There is no need to send Bangladeshi infiltrators to court. We have a provision in the law that allows the police to directly hand them over to the Border Security Force [BSF], who in turn will ascertain whether the person handed over is a Bangladeshi or not... Why should we keep them in jail for three months or six months, or even two years, and provide them with your rice, dal, oil, fish, eggs, medicines? Are they our sons-in-law?” he demanded.

Attacking the previous government, Adhikari said that the Trinamool had turned a blind eye to the matter even though there were existing laws to deport Bangladeshis. “Some people did not use [the laws] for the sake of vote-bank interests. We are implementing the laws in the interest of the country and the State,” said Adhikari.

A government-owned building that has been converted into a holding centre at Tentulia in North 24 Parganas district, not very far from the Hakimpur checkpost.

A government-owned building that has been converted into a holding centre at Tentulia in North 24 Parganas district, not very far from the Hakimpur checkpost. | Photo Credit: JAYANTA SHAW

Union Home Minister Amit Shah also urged Bangladeshi immigrants to leave voluntarily to avoid state action. “Bengal government has made detention centres. But we want all those who had entered illegally to go back voluntarily. If they do, the State government will not file any case against them; and instead, it will help them to get back to their own country,” said Shah at a public rally in Gandhinagar on May 28.

What if genuine Indian citizens get targeted?

Not everyone is comfortable about the holding centres. It is feared that this frenzied process of tracking down foreigners will end up targeting genuine Indian citizens whose names have been deleted during the SIR exercise because of “logical discrepancy”. What if such people are labelled Bangladeshis and put in the holding centres?

Asif Faruk, general secretary of Migrant Labourer Unity Forum, an organisation that assists migrants in times of distress, said: “The state needs to ensure that no genuine citizen is harassed. We have seen how migrant workers from West Bengal, who are Indian citizens, were labelled Bangladeshis simply for being Bengali-speaking Muslims and pushed into Bangladesh. Even now, there are at least four migrant workers from West Bengal, all Indian citizens, who are still stranded in Bangladesh, after being forced across the border by the BSF.”

“With anti-Muslim emotions running high in the country and in post-BJP Bengal, both paperless immigrants and innocents are likely to get caught.”

The main opposition party, the Trinamool Congress, made no bones about its reservations regarding the holding centres. Addressing a press conference, party spokesperson and MLA Kunal Ghosh said, “We are staunchly against such detention camps. If any Bangladeshi infiltrator had entered Bengal, then the primary responsibility lies with the BSF, which is under the Central government… the government should follow the existing process—arrest the infiltrator, produce him in court, the court then sends him to jail; and from there he is pushed back into Bangladesh… There is also the danger of people falling prey to vindictive politics and falsely being put in these centres. First let the issue of legitimate voters be resolved.”

The Congress voiced the same concern. While maintaining that no illegal immigrant should be allowed to stay, it warned that innocent people should not be harassed.

Senior Congress leader Amitava Chakraborty told Frontline, “While there is no argument against illegal infiltrators being removed, those people whose names have been deleted in the SIR should not summarily be put into these camps. The Election Commission cannot decide citizenship; it is the Home Ministry’s job. If a person is targeted only for being a Muslim and labelled a Bangladeshi, the Congress will not stand for it.”

Ultimately, that is the danger. With anti-Muslim emotions running high in the country and in post-BJP Bengal, both paperless immigrants and innocents are likely to get caught.

Also Read | The polarisation project in Assam

Also Read | Pushed out, brought back, but at what cost?