If I’m wearing blue mascara, chances are it’s this one. Not only is this formula really opaque on my dark-brown lashes in just a few swipes, but it doesn’t clump no matter how much you layer on. It also adds so much volume to really open up my eyes.

Sometimes, I want a wash of blue over my lashes without going full drama. In those cases, Maybelline’s Sky High is perfect. It coats my lashes in blue pigment while lengthening and separating them. Obviously, it’s blue, which isn’t “natural” per se, but the effect of the mascara is more subtle.

Navy probably isn’t what you think of when your mind goes to blue mascara, but it’s actually so chic. It’s a more subdued way to wear blue, but as your lashes catch the light, you can tell there’s something a bit cooler than a standard black on ‘em. This mascara is also amazing for keeping my straight, fine lashes curled all day.

If you wanna just try out blue mascara without committing to a high price tag, L’Oréal Voluminous in blue is pretty damn good for less than $10. The medium-blue shade covers every lash for a bright wash of color, but the actual formula itself is easy to apply and add a few coats for volume and length. It’s also very easy to wash off, which is helpful when you don’t want flakes of blue all over your face at the end of the day.