Kaylee and Summit were literally the one success story on season 2 of Netflix’s Temptation Island and truly gave us hope that this messy reality show can actually work! Buuut it looks like they might have recently broken up? Emphasis on might since things are pretty murky and fans are now reading into a comment Summit dropped on Instagram.

The video in question? Summit reuniting with the rest of the Temptation Island guys in anticipation of the reunion and making a crying face at the camera.

Kay, so the crying face alone means approximately nothing (it was an emotional season!), but Summit also pinned the comment “It’s too bad all of our ladies left us :(” Replies to this are mixed, with some people worried he and Kaylee broke up, and others thinking that he’s making a joke. Either way, the vibes between him and Kaylee seem fine in this follow-up cast vid!

And let’s not forget that they both posted from the same Tennessee location just a few days before, which strongly implies everything is just fine between them. Either way, we’ll be finding out during the Temptation Island reunion episode, on which the cast will gather to give us updates on where things stand in their relationships. VERY curious to find out if anyone got back together, not to mention clear things up with this Summit-Kaylee situation!