Getty

Anthony Volpe faces renewed pressure after the New York Yankees made a surprising prospect decision, according to one analyst.

A surprising Yankees prospect decision has put Anthony Volpe on notice as George Lombard Jr. is climbing faster than expected. New York on Tuesday night promoted 20-year-old infielder George Lombard Jr., the organization’s No. 1 prospect, from Double-A Somerset to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre during their series against the Texas Rangers. The move, first reported by YES Network’s Jack Curry, comes as Volpe continues his rehab assignment with no firm return timetable.

The promotion matters now because Volpe’s return remains uncertain and the Yankees may soon need another infield answer. Entering 2026, general manager Brian Cashman described 2027 as the more realistic timetable for Lombard to reach the Bronx, per Sports Illustrated. A scorching Double-A start altered that projection quickly. Lombard entered Tuesday batting .324 with four home runs, 10 RBIs and a 163 wRC+ across 20 games at the Double-A level.

Lombard Jr. Promotion Creates New Yankees Shortstop Question

Ranked by MLB Pipeline as the No. 27 overall prospect in baseball entering this season, Lombard has been considered major league-ready defensively by Cashman’s own public assessment. The bat was the open question entering 2026. His .215 slash line across nearly 470 plate appearances at Double-A in 2025 left real doubt. His production this spring set those reservations to rest.

Per Curry, Lombard will play both shortstop and third base for the Triple-A RailRiders, with second base also in his range. That versatility gives Aaron Boone genuine options for working him into the big-league picture without an outright displacement of Volpe, if Volpe returns and holds his job.

Volpe Return Date Still Unclear for Yankees

The Yankees do not yet know whether Volpe will be available against the Baltimore Orioles this weekend, per SNY‘s John Flanigan. Boone said Monday that Volpe will continue his rehab at Double-A Somerset on Tuesday and Wednesday before the club reassesses. He has hit .308 with a home run and three RBIs across eight minor league games recovering from left shoulder surgery last October. If Volpe struggles after returning, Lombard’s timetable becomes more than a minor-league storyline.

The roster has no margin for a prolonged wait. Giancarlo Stanton landed on the 10-day injured list Monday with a low-grade right calf strain, and Jasson Dominguez was recalled the same day. When Volpe is cleared, a spot must open immediately. Analyst Esteban Quiñones of Pinstripes Nation identified veteran first baseman Paul Goldschmidt as the player most likely to be displaced.

Goldschmidt, 38, was brought back to platoon against left-handed pitching but is batting .111 with a .527 OPS against southpaws through 23 plate appearances. Ben Rice has made the role redundant, hitting .304/.407/.696 against lefties. Goldschmidt’s close friendship with captain Aaron Judge — the two bonded during workouts in the 2021-22 lockout — makes any decision to cut ties more complicated. But a team built for October has little room for sentimentality.

The Lombard development adds a longer-term dimension to an already complicated picture. Cashman said 2027. George Lombard Jr. may be forcing that timeline into 2026 — while Anthony Volpe tries to hold the job now.