“They feel like both sides fucking hate them,” says independent journalist Karl Loftus

Inside Alligator Alcatraz — the controversial, recently shuttered immigration detention camp in Everglades — there was a small chain-link cage roughly the size of a coffin in the middle of the rec yard, underneath the baking Florida sun. The guards called it “the box.” Detainees would be placed inside at any time of day, fed their meals through the bars — turkey sandwiches, a granola bar, and little else. The mosquitos would eat them alive. 

“If you’re out there in the box, then you’re fucked,” one guard said.

The guard’s quote, and the anecdotes and details in the paragraph above, weren’t revealed to Rolling Stone, or 60 Minutes, or The New York Times. Instead, we know them because both a guard and an inmate detained at Alligator Alcatraz spoke to independent journalist Karl Loftus, who for the past six months has been publishing unfiltered, raw interviews with the people at the heart of Donald Trump’s immigration crackdown: ICE Agents, private prison guards, Homeland Security Investigators, and other cops. Members of these groups are often incredibly reluctant to talk to the mainstream press, but Loftus’ position as a neutral party, who is already plugged into the world of cops and military veterans, has given him a unique window into the lives and opinions of the other side of the war on immigration. What they’ve revealed has been shocking, frustrating, and also deeply humanizing to the many officials who have been tasked with enforcing a policy agenda that they did not set, and often disagree with.

“I think these guys are super frustrated with their agency,” Loftus tells Rolling Stone. “They just want the truth to come out.”

Loftus’ route to journalism was non-traditional as well. For most of his adult life – he’s 39 – he worked blue-collar trade jobs, before getting into disaster relief work in the late 2010s. While working relief operations for Hurricane Helene, he was shocked by the exploitative and inefficient practices of many of the companies contracted to help rebuild wide stretches of the country. He started documenting what he saw — interviews with residents, investigations into shady companies, and real footage from the situation on the ground. His work gained a modest following, many of whom had connections to the disaster relief industry, which has a heavy overlap with veterans and law enforcement officers. But in the winter of 2026, another kind of disaster struck: Operation Metro Surge, a widespread, brutal immigration crackdown in Minneapolis, Minnesota. Loftus, fresh off a deployment to Hurricane Melissa in Jamaica, got in his car and drove through the night from his family home Wisconsin, aiming to document what was happening on the ground. But his big break came online, when he posted footage of Alex Pretti’s shooting and asked veterans and law enforcement officers on his page for their response. Those interactions, he says, put him in touch with the first ICE officer he interviewed.

Editor’s picks

“I started this as, ‘Oh shit, this is an opportunity — no one’s talked to these guys.’ I was just hyped on that,” Loftus says. “The audience’s reaction is what opened my eyes to just how important it was.”

As it turns out, readers on both the left and the right were interested in hearing from the officers themselves — especially when their points of view weren’t what either side expected. 

“It’s not healthy to see our world as only us and them,” one user commented on an early Instagram post. “Thank you for expanding our awareness.”

Loftus edited, condensed, and curated many of his interviews, cribbing pull quotes that he knew would do well on social media. As a whole, the interviews paint a uniquely well-sourced and ultimately unflattering picture of the Trump administration’s immigration policies. But Loftus says that none of that would have worked if he hadn’t taken what the agents had to say at face value, giving them a neutral platform to express their own views.

Related Content

“It was never my goal to put the injustices of the administration out there,” Loftus says. “I have no interest in just becoming another echo chamber page that’s just like ‘fuck Trump, fuck all this stuff.’ That would just be so unfulfilling to me.”

That neutrality brought him quotes from frustrated agents despairing at Trump’s policies — many of which garnered thousands of views and brought in more followers. “Sometimes it does feel like I’m running a federal government employee complaint line,” he says.

“I’ve considered quitting multiple times,” an investigator with Homeland Security told Loftus. “Being told to pause ongoing child sexual abuse investigations… to go help ERO (Enforcement and Removal Operations) arrest an illegal immigrant with no criminal history? It’s a slap in the face. All these activists want us to quit. But who would that hurt the most? The victims we are supposed to be helping, that’s who.”

Loftus also documented other unfiltered points of view, including bloodthirsty rants from other officers who were furious with the left-wing media. 

“I would love to throat punch some purple-haired liberal protesters,” one Homeland Security agent told Loftus. “I started out in Border Patrol, so the Border Patrol agent in me wants to fuck people up writ large, but I have to balance that with the fact that I have [redacted] days left in a [redacted] year career.”

Loftus says quotes like this were outliers. Many of the agents had complex, detailed opinions on the actions of their fellow officers and the jobs they were being tasked to do. Loftus says that he has a thorough system of verification for his interviews, often testing his anonymous sources with a series of questions that only someone in their stated job would know, a process he said some of his first DHS and ICE sources helped him set up. Some officers, however, have just sent him photos of their badges or IDs directly. 

“There are subtle aspects to being in DHS that you can easily spot a poser,” one HSI agent who has helped vet testimonies told Loftus.

It’s a system that would never fly at, say, The New York Times or CNN. And it’s entirely possible that some portion of Loftus’ dozens of interviews were by impostors pushing an agenda. Loftus works alone, for the most part, publishing his content on Patreon, Instagram, and other social media pages. That independence will always come with risks. But, he says, it’s also been the foundation of an extraordinary amount of access into one of the most opaque and bureaucratic agencies in the Trump administration.

Many of the officers Loftus has spoken to feel like they’re caught between two harsh, inflexible political movements. One side sees their participation in brutal, inhumane immigration policies as an indelible moral stain. The other expects them to do their jobs enforcing those policies without complaint.

“They feel like both sides fucking hate them,” Loftus says. “One of the biggest takeaways for me is how fragile the support for law enforcement is. The second these guys start complaining, the ‘Back the Blue’ crowd is like ‘Shut the fuck up, quit then.’”

Loftus thinks the reaction to his work is proof that there is a real need for journalism that doesn’t conform to the prevailing narratives on either the left or the right. 

“I’m not a Democrat or Republican — I try to keep identity politics out of my soul as much as possible,” Loftus says. “There’s a very obvious anti-law enforcement perspective from the left, and the opposite from the right. I learned how thin and uninformed both those perspectives are.”

Trending Stories

And thus far, it seems like his approach is working: the testimonies keep flooding in. He’s applied the same techniques to interviews with anonymous undocumented immigrants, former ICE detainees, and anti-fascist protesters. 

“I’ve always been kinda obsessed about this idea that you can talk about an extremely polarizing subject and not lose half your audience, where you don’t just become an echo chamber.” Loftus says. “I think I’ve done that — and I think that’s a big part of why I’m inspired to keep doing it.”