MAMANUCA ISLANDS, FIJI—In a revelation that prompted widespread calls for producers to remove him from the reality show’s villa, Love Island USA contestant Bryce Dettloff reportedly found himself under fire Thursday after newly surfaced photos showed the cast member wearing a shirt. “This is a total betrayal of viewers,” fan Kayla Robinson said of the shocking Instagram photo internet sleuths dug up from 2019, adding that the then-23-year-old Dettloff had exhibited a disturbing lack of judgment by posing in a polyester crew neck. “How am I supposed to get caught up in this season’s romance when I know that Bryce was once clothed? The casting directors really dropped the ball on the vetting process here—they should have done their due diligence to confirm that every male contestant has been shirtless for the entirety of their years on earth.” At press time, a fully nude Dettloff had posted a video to his social channels asserting that the old photo in no way represented the hunk of a man he is today.