Channel state information (CSI)-based neural positioning learns a mapping from CSI measurements to user equipment (UE) positions using neural networks. However, most existing performance evaluations utilize randomly partitioned train/test CSI-dataset splits, which fail to reflect the generalization requirements of practical deployments and present optimistic results. In this paper, we study the spatial and temporal generalization of neural positioning with standard-compliant Wi-Fi and 5G NR systems for three real-world CSI datasets acquired in indoor and outdoor environments. We assess generalization with two different architectures, a conventional multilayer perceptron (MLP) and a novel transformer architecture, to unseen spatial regions, unseen UE trajectories, and CSI measurement campaigns separated by one week. Our experiments show that both architectures generalize well in space and time, and the proposed transformer consistently outperforms the MLP in positioning accuracy while requiring fewer model parameters.