Pointwise maximal leakage (PML) is an operationally meaningful privacy measure that quantifies the amount of information leaking about a secret $X$ to a single outcome of a related random variable $Y$. In this paper, we extend the notion of PML to random variables on arbitrary probability spaces. We develop two new definitions: First, we extend PML to countably infinite random variables by considering adversaries who aim to guess the value of discrete (finite or countably infinite) functions of $X$. Then, we consider adversaries who construct estimates of $X$ that maximize the expected value of their corresponding gain functions. We use this latter setup to introduce a highly versatile form of PML that captures many scenarios of practical interest whose definition requires no assumptions about the underlying probability spaces.