With the prevalence of artificial intelligence (AI)-generated content, such as audio deepfakes, a large body of recent work has focused on developing deepfake detection techniques. However, existing benchmarks employ a narrow set of datasets, leaving detector generalization to real-world conditions uncertain. In this paper, we systematically review 31 existing audio deepfake datasets and present an open-source benchmarking toolkit called AUDDT (https://github.com/MuSAELab/AUDDT). The goal of this toolkit is to automate the evaluation of pretrained detectors across a wide range of speech and non-speech audio datasets, giving users direct feedback on the advantages and shortcomings of their deepfake detectors under diverse manipulation types and recording conditions. We start by showcasing the usage of the developed toolkit, the composition of our benchmark, and the breakdown of different deepfake subgroups. Next, we highlight how AUDDT differs from existing benchmarking efforts by enabling large-scale, diverse evaluation across modern spoofing methods and richer attribute-level analysis through comprehensive metadata annotation. Using a widely adopted pretrained deepfake detector, we present in- and out-of-domain detection results, revealing notable performance variability across different conditions and audio manipulation types. Lastly, we also analyze the limitations of these existing datasets and their gaps relative to practical deployment scenarios.