This paper presents two results concerning uniform confidence intervals for the tail index and the extreme quantile. First, we show that it is impossible to construct a length-optimal confidence interval satisfying the correct uniform coverage over a local non-parametric family of tail distributions. Second, in light of the impossibility result, we construct honest confidence intervals that are uniformly valid by incorporating the worst-case bias in the local non-parametric family. The proposed method is applied to simulated data and a real data set of National Vital Statistics from National Center for Health Statistics.