We study the optimal sustainable harvesting of a population that lives in a random environment. The novelty of our setting is that we maximize the asymptotic harvesting yield, both in an expected value and almost sure sense, for a large class of harvesting strategies and unstructured population models. We prove under relatively weak assumptions that there exists a unique optimal harvesting strategy characterized by an optimal threshold below which the population is maintained at all times by utilizing a local time push-type policy. We also discuss, through Abelian limits, how our results are related to the optimal harvesting strategies when one maximizes the expected cumulative present value of the harvesting yield and establish a simple connection and ordering between the values and optimal boundaries. Finally, we explicitly characterize the optimal harvesting strategies in two different cases, one of which is the celebrated stochastic Verhulst Pearl logistic model of population growth.