Let $p_n$ be a random, degree $n$ polynomial whose roots are chosen independently according to the probability measure $μ$ on the complex plane. For a deterministic point $ξ$ lying outside the support of $μ$, we show that almost surely the polynomial $q_n(z):=p_n(z)(z - ξ)$ has a critical point at distance $O(1/n)$ from $ξ$. In other words, conditioning the random polynomials $p_n$ to have a root at $ξ$, almost surely forces a critical point near $ξ$. More generally, we prove an analogous result for the critical points of $q_n(z):=p_n(z)(z - ξ_1)\cdots (z - ξ_k)$, where $ξ_1, \ldots, ξ_k$ are deterministic. In addition, when $k=o(n)$, we show that the empirical distribution constructed from the critical points of $q_n$ converges to $μ$ in probability as the degree tends to infinity, extending a recent result of Kabluchko.