In this work, we give a characterization of Lipschitz operators on spaces of $C^2(M)$ functions (also $C^{1,1}$, $C^{1,γ}$, $C^1$, $C^γ$) that obey the global comparison property-- i.e. those that preserve the global ordering of input functions at any points where their graphs may touch, often called "elliptic" operators. Here $M$ is a complete Riemannian manifold. In particular, we show that all such operators can be written as a min-max over linear operators that are a combination of drift-diffusion and integro-differential parts. In the \emph{linear} (and nonlocal) case, Courrège had characterized these operators in the 1960's, and in the \emph{local, but nonlinear} case-- e.g. local Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman operators-- this characterization has also been known for quite some time. Our result gives both a nonlinear extension of Courrège's and a nonlocal extension of well known results for local Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equations. It also shows any nonlinear scalar elliptic equation can be represented as an Isaacs equation for an appropriate differential game. Our approach is to "project" the operator to a finite dimensional space, where a min-max formula is easier, and then the min-max can be appropriately lifted to the original operator on the infinite dimensional space. As one application, we mention some preliminary results about the structure of Dirichlet-to-Neumann mappings for second order elliptic equations, including fully nonlinear equations. This is the Director's cut, and it contains extra details for our own sanity.