We give tightness criteria for random variables taking values in the space of all compact sets of cadlag real-valued paths, in terms of both the Skorohod J1 and M1 topologies. This extends earlier work motivated by the study of the Brownian web that was concerned only with continuous paths. In the M1 case, we give a natural extension of our tightness criteria which ensures that non-crossing systems of paths have weak limit points that are also non-crossing. This last result is exemplified through a rescaling of heavy tailed Poisson trees and a more general application to weaves.