$GQ$ functions are symmetric functions indexed by strict partitions that represent $K$-theoretic Schubert classes in the Lagrangian Grassmannian. Buch and Ravikumar proved a Pieri rule for expanding $GQ_λ\cdot GQ_p$ in terms of $GQ$s via certain shifted skew tableaux. In this paper we identify an alternative family of shifted tableaux that enumerates this Pieri rule. This partially resolves a conjecture from previous work that these tableaux enumerate the expansion of $GQ_λ \cdot GQ_τ$ in terms of $GQ$s where $τ$ is a trapezoid shape.