In this paper we determine the maximum number of points in $\mathbb{R}^d$ which form exactly $t$ distinct triangles, where we restrict ourselves to the case of $t = 1$. We denote this quantity by $F_d(t)$. It was known from the work of Epstein et al. that $F_2(1) = 4$. Here we show somewhat surprisingly that $F_3(1) = 4$ and $F_d(1) = d + 1$, whenever $d \geq 3$, and characterize the optimal point configurations. This is an extension of a variant of the distinct distance problem put forward by Erdős and Fishburn.