We study random generation in the symmetric group when cycle type restrictions are imposed. Given $π, π' \in S_n$, we prove that $π$ and a random conjugate of $π'$ are likely to generate at least $A_n$ provided only that $π$ and $π'$ have not too many fixed points and not too many $2$-cycles. As an application, we investigate the following question: For which positive integers $m$ should we expect two random elements of order $m$ to generate $A_n$? Among other things, we give a positive answer for any $m$ having any divisor $d$ in the range $3 \leq d \leq o(n^{1/2})$.