Using cyclotomy, we construct a new infinite family of Neumaier graphs that includes infinitely many strongly regular graphs. Notably, this family conjecturally contains infinitely many graphs with coherent rank $6$. Our construction also provides the first known examples that answer a question posed by Evans, Goryainov, and Panasenko regarding the existence of Neumaier graphs whose nexus is not a power of $2$. In addition, we show that a construction of Greaves and Koolen yields an infinite family of Neumaier graphs with coherent rank $6$.