We introduce the Macdonald piece polynomial $\operatorname{I}_{μ,λ,k}[X;q,t]$, which is a vast generalization of the Macdonald intersection polynomial in the science fiction conjecture by Bergeron and Garsia. We demonstrate a remarkable connection between $\operatorname{I}_{μ,λ,k}$, $\nabla s_λ$, and the Loehr--Warrington formula $\operatorname{LW}_λ$, thereby obtaining the Loehr--Warrington conjecture as a corollary. To connect $\operatorname{I}_{μ,λ,k}$ and $\nabla s_λ$, we employ the plethystic formula for the Macdonald polynomials of Garsia--Haiman--Tesler, and to connect $\operatorname{I}_{μ,λ,k}$ and $\operatorname{LW}_λ$, we use our new findings on the combinatorics of $P$-tableaux together with the column exchange rule. We also present an extension of the science fiction conjecture and the Macdonald positivity by exploiting $\operatorname{I}_{μ,λ,k}$.