We study a generalization of a famous result of Goodman and establish that asymptotically at least a $1/256$ fraction of all triangles needs to be monochromatic in any four-coloring of the edges of a complete graph. We also show that any large enough extremal construction must be based on a blow-up of one of the two $R(3,3,3)$ Ramsey-colorings of $K_{16}$. This result is obtained through an efficient flag algebra formulation by exploiting problem-specific combinatorial symmetries that also allows us to study some related problems.