We introduce the extra slow Tamari lattices, a new family of lattices defined on faithfully balanced tableaux. These tableaux arise naturally from the representation theory of type \( A \) quivers, and our construction extends the classical Tamari lattice and the slow Tamari lattice. We explicitly describe meets and joins in the extra slow Tamari lattices, and then prove that they are lattices. We then show that they are semidistributive, trim, polygonal, and congruence uniform. Their join-irreducible elements are described in terms of a three-color analogue of the positive roots of type \( A \), which leads to descriptions of their spines and congruence lattices. We also obtain several enumerative results for the extra slow Tamari lattices and their associated structures. Finally, we derive new structural and enumerative results for the slow Tamari lattices.