We conjecture a formula for the rational $q,t$-Catalan polynomial $\mathcal{C}_{r/s}$ that is symmetric in $q$ and $t$ by definition. The conjecture posits that $\mathcal{C}_{r/s}$ can be written in terms of symmetric monomial strings indexed by maximal Dyck paths. We show that for any finite $d^*$, giving a combinatorial proof of our conjecture on the infinite set of functions $\{ \mathcal{C}_{r/s}^d: r\equiv 1 \mod s, \,\,\, d \leq d^*\}$ is equivalent to a finite counting problem.