Inspired by a common technique for shuffling a deck of cards on a table without riffling, we formalize the pile shuffle and investigate its capabilities as a sorting device. Our study is novel in that we consider pile shuffle in three variations: (1) using queue-like piles, (2) using stack-like piles, and (3) using a heterogeneous mixture of those two pile types, either given or decided during the shuffle by the dealer herself. We first characterize the sortable permutations of one or more sequential rounds of pile shuffle, under constraints on the number and types of piles to be used, and then derive formulas to obtain a sorting shuffle of a given permutation on the minimum number of piles, efficiently, whenever feasible. In the process, we present an interesting mathematical interpretation of any multi-round shuffle on fixed-type piles, as a single-round shuffle on a generally larger number of fixed-type ``virtual piles''; we confirm that repetition augments the power of pile shuffle exponentially, in that $m$ piles over $T$ rounds enjoys the capacity of $m^T$ piles in a single round. Finally, we motivate a forthcoming companion paper in which we prove that dealer choice -- where the dealer is allowed to choose the types of the piles during the shuffle -- makes deciding feasibility of sort NP-Hard for some variants of multi-round pile shuffle; proof is by a novel reduction from Boolean satisfiability (SAT).