A $(4, 5)$-coloring of $K_n$ is an edge-coloring of $K_n$ where every $4$-clique spans at least five colors. We show that there exist $(4, 5)$-colorings of $K_n$ using $\frac 56 n + o(n)$ colors. This settles a disagreement between Erdős and Gyárfás reported in their 1997 paper. Our construction uses a randomized process which we analyze using the so-called differential equation method to establish dynamic concentration. In particular, our coloring process uses random triangle removal, a process first introduced by Bollobás and Erdős, and analyzed by Bohman, Frieze and Lubetzky.