Modern pattern recognition tasks use complex algorithms that take advantage of large datasets to make more accurate predictions than traditional algorithms such as decision trees or k-nearest-neighbor better suited to describe simple structures. While increased accuracy is often crucial, less complexity also has value. This paper proposes a training data selection algorithm that identifies multiple subsets with simple structures. A learning algorithm trained on such a subset can classify an instance belonging to the subset with better accuracy than the traditional learning algorithms. In other words, while existing pattern recognition algorithms attempt to learn a global mapping function to represent the entire dataset, we argue that an ensemble of simple local patterns may better describe the data. Hence the sub-setting algorithm identifies multiple subsets with simple local patterns by identifying similar instances in the neighborhood of an instance. This motivation has similarities to that of gradient boosted trees but focuses on the explainability of the model that is missing for boosted trees. The proposed algorithm thus balances accuracy and explainable machine learning by identifying a limited number of subsets with simple structures. We applied the proposed algorithm to the international stroke dataset to predict the probability of survival. Our bottom-up sub-setting algorithm performed on an average 15% better than the top-down decision tree learned on the entire dataset. The different decision trees learned on the identified subsets use some of the previously unused features by the whole dataset decision tree, and each subset represents a distinct population of data.