Despite the potential the ability to identify granular materials creates for applications such as robotic cooking or earthmoving, granular material identification remains a challenging area, existing methods mostly relying on shaking the materials in closed containers. This work presents an interactive material identification framework that enables robots to identify a wide range of granular materials using only force-torque measurements. Unlike prior works, the proposed approach uses direct interaction with the materials. The approach is evaluated through experiments with a real-world dataset comprising 11 granular materials, which we also make publicly available. Results show that our method can identify a wide range of granular materials with near-perfect accuracy while relying solely on force measurements obtained from direct interaction. Further, our comprehensive data analysis and experiments show that a high-performancefeature space must combine features related to the force signal's time-domain dynamics and frequency spectrum. We account for this by proposing a combination of the raw signal and its high-frequency magnitude histogram as the suggested feature space representation. We show that the proposed feature space outperforms baselines by a significant margin. The code and data set are available at: https://irobotics.aalto.fi/identify_granular/.