We provide an end-to-end Renyi DP based-framework for differentially private top-$k$ selection. Unlike previous approaches, which require a data-independent choice on $k$, we propose to privately release a data-dependent choice of $k$ such that the gap between $k$-th and the $(k+1)$st "quality" is large. This is achieved by a novel application of the Report-Noisy-Max. Not only does this eliminate one hyperparameter, the adaptive choice of $k$ also certifies the stability of the top-$k$ indices in the unordered set so we can release them using a variant of propose-test-release (PTR) without adding noise. We show that our construction improves the privacy-utility trade-offs compared to the previous top-$k$ selection algorithms theoretically and empirically. Additionally, we apply our algorithm to "Private Aggregation of Teacher Ensembles (PATE)" in multi-label classification tasks with a large number of labels and show that it leads to significant performance gains.