This time, Leonardo was the only person to send her something back. 

“I did a joke about Leonardo DiCaprio, which I was really struggling with because I was like, 'I just don't want to make the joke about how he has young girlfriends. It's been done so many times,’” she explained to host Jimmy Fallon. “That joke's been going on longer than his current girlfriend's been alive."

So, Nikki decided to take a different approach when teasing the 51-year-old—who has been in a relationship with model Vittoria Ceretti, 27, since 2023.

"Me and my writing team found a Teen Beat article from 1991," Nikki recalled. "I was like, 'Leo, we don't know anything about you. The only thing we know about you is from a Teen Beat article in 1991, where you told us your favorite food is pasta, pasta, and more pasta.'"

"He sent me three baskets of pasta as a thank you," Nikki added. "He sent me pasta. So funny. So good. Part of me was like, 'Does Leo want to smash?' Like, I was like, 'All right.' Then I was like, 'The type of girl he goes for, he wouldn't send pasta to.’ It was a dry pasta."

But Leo’s love for pasta wasn’t the only thing he talked about in his Teen Beat interview as the Oscar winner also touched on his love for Lord of the Flies, basketball, baseball, Pink Floyd and MC Hammer's "U Can't Touch This."

As for how Leo reacted to her reveal at the Golden Globes? The Titanic actor appeared delighted, laughing and giving Nikki a thumbs up from the audience.

For a look at the Oscar winner through the years, keep reading.