After she gathered the Haim sisters for a girls night at the historic New York Knicks game earlier this week, Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce got back into their date night swing to see Broadway’s buzziest play.

Swift and Kelce stepped out for a late afternoon performance of Oh, Mary! starring Maya Rudolph. The couple kept to their own style codes, but coordinated on a reddish color palette. Taylor, for one, opted for a deep wine, velvet Ralph Lauren tank dress paired with a Chloé bracelet hobo bag, and gold Aquazurra sandals. For jewelry, she kept to her golds: a Love Adorned Isadora ring, a Danes Road Antiques opal bracelet and matching opal and diamond ring, a Michael Anthony moon pendant, and her Kindred Lubeck engagement ring.

Swift wore her hair up in a side swept bun and her signature red lip.

Kelce sported a red floral Valentino Garavani bowling shirt, a red and blue striped Elwood cap, and black suit pants. The Kansas City Chiefs athlete’s penchant for a vintage style bowling shirt knows no bounds.

The couple made their way backstage after the performance to meet and mingle with the cast, and posed for photos with Rudolph and director Sam Pinkleton.

Whether they’re hitting up Romeo & Juliet on London’s West End or sitting courtside, Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce have very much found a date night style formula that suits their shared love of an “activities” date: Will we see them on the skittles before their imminent wedding?