From landing late in New York on Thursday night to first pitch in The Bronx on Friday, Pete Alonso had already taken several trips down memory lane on his initial return to his former home of over seven years. 

He stumbled over a few words when expressing what it means to him to be back in the city after leaving the Mets for a five-year, $155 million deal with the Orioles. 

Alonso immediately thought of his first taste of professional baseball with the Brooklyn Cyclones in 2016. He remembered playoff moments from 2022 and ’24 — the “most special baseball” he played. 

He also reflected on his last time in New York. The Mets finished off an 11-inning game against the Nationals in their final homestand of the 2025 season and the next day, he and wife Haley went to Mount Sinai Hospital to welcome their first child together, a boy. 

“There’s a lot of things you think about after being here for so long,” Alonso said before the Orioles’ 7-2 loss to the Yankees. “Being in Manhattan, in the city, just looking back and thinking about that is really special.” 

Alonso continued to leave his mark on the city, hitting a home run off Will Warren in his first at-bat Friday. He went 1-for-2 with two walks and scored both of the Orioles’ runs. 

Walking around Friday, the five-time All-Star felt he was “just back in the old neighborhood.” 

He spent time pondering some of his favorite restaurants in the city, citing his favorite Italian spot, Ci Siamo, as a must-visit. “Shoutout chef Hillary,” he said. 

The 31-year-old didn’t assume anything about the game that preceded his son’s birth, whether it would be his last game at Citi Field. 

“I wasn’t thinking about it,” he said. “I was just more thinking about, ‘I can’t believe the season is over,’ because there was hopes for more, but obviously we didn’t do the job at the time. I was more shifted to family and how it was time to be dad, be husband. Let the dust settle and enjoy being parents for the first time. 

“That was where my mind was at initially. I didn’t really start thinking about free agency until the World Series was over.” 

Since arriving in Baltimore, Alonso hasn’t yet brought his best to the plate. Entering Friday, he was hitting .198 with four home runs and a .668 OPS through 31 games.