The Justice Warriors are back for a whole lot of mama (and papa) drama.

True Justice: Eye For An Eye marks Hallmark Channel‘s second True Justice film, once again centering on a group of friends and law students who take matters into their own hands to solve a case. This time, they “take a trip back to high school to exonerate a wrongfully convicted wife, mother, and passionate student advocate,” specifically, Penn Charter’s Parent School Coalition President Sharon Warner, who “is convicted for the vehicular homicide of fellow PSC member.”

Deadline reported in February 2025 that production had kicked off on two True Justice sequels to follow 2024’s True Justice: Family Ties. According to the outlet, the working title for the third film in the True Justice series is True Justice: Lost Love.

Those who have watched (and maybe even rewatched) True Justice: Family Ties will recognize many returning faces, who lead this new title. True Justice: Eye For An Eye premieres tonight at 8/7 c on Hallmark Channel, with next-day streaming available on Hallmark+. But before you settle down to watch this new legal thriller, refresh yourselves on the True Justice cast with our cast guide, which you can check out below.

Warning: Light spoilers ahead for True Justice: Eye For An Eye!

1. Katherine McNamara as Casey Barlowe

   Casey Barlowe (Katherine McNamara) is a law student, who with the help of her friends, helped clear her brother Marcus’ (Sam Ashe Arnold) name after he was accused of murder in True Justice: Family Ties. Another case brought to her and the gang by Liam (see below) piques her interest in True Justice: Eye For An Eye. Hallmark Channel describes Casey as “passionate and resourceful.”

   As mentioned above, McNamara is reprising her role as Casey from True Justice: Family Ties. She is known for her work on Shadowhunters, Arrow, and Walker: Independence, in addition to films like 2015’s Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials and 2018’s Maze Runner: The Death Cure.

2. Markian Tarasiuk as Eli Flint

   Markian Tarasiuk plays Eli Flint, a law student and friend of Casey, Sarah, and Liam, who values the way Casey united them to become the Justice Warriors. They were initially adversaries in True Justice: Family Ties, as he believed her brother murdered his girlfriend. The network describes Eli as “bold and decisive.”

   Tarasiuk is another returning cast member from True Justice: Family Ties. Other Hallmark movies of his include A Homecoming for the Holidays (2019), Christmas at the Golden Dragon (2022), and Nelly Knows Mysteries: All Manners of Murder (2024).

3. Alexander Nuñez as Liam Anderson

   Liam (Alexander Nuñez) is a private investigator and a friend of Casey, Eli, and Sarah, who brings them Sharon Warner’s case. As Hallmark notes, Liam is “cunning and creative.”

   Like his other five co-stars, Nuñez is reprising his role from True Justice: Family Ties. He recently appeared in an episode of Fox‘s Memory of A Killer, and has also made cameos on The Bold Type, The Handmaid’s Tale, The Umbrella Academy, and Private Eyes.

4. Marisa McIntyre as Sarah Sharpe

   Sarah Sharpe (played by Marisa McIntyre) is also a law student and friend of Casey’s since undergrad, who helps the Justice Warriors by testing prints and DNA in her lab. Per Hallmark’s recent post, Sarah is “observant and supportive.”

   McIntyre is another True Justice: Family Ties alum. Among her TV credits are Chucky, PAW Patrol, Murdoch Mysteries, and The Last Frontier.

5. Nikki DeLoach as Professor Ambrose

   Professor Ambrose (Nikki DeLoach) is a law professor at Pennbrooks, whose students include Casey, Eli, and Marisa (see below). She is a source of sage advice for her students, and is also in a relationship with D.A. Quinn (once again, see below). According to Hallmark’s description of Professor Ambrose, she is “insightful and through.”

   Long before her tenure at Hallmark began, DeLoach starred on The All-New Mickey Mouse Club with fellow rising stars like Christina Aguilera, Justin Timberlake, and Ryan Gosling. DeLoach appeared in her first Hallmark movie in 2015, and has since become a network name, recently starring in last year’s A Grand Ole Opry Christmas alongside Kristoffer Polaha.

6. Benjamin Ayres as D.A. Quinn

   Benjamin Ayres returns to the True Justice film series as District Attorney Quinn. Like Professor Ambrose, Quinn is eager to help her students where he can as they pursue cases. D.A. Quinn is “helpful and determined,” per Hallmark’s description of the character.

   Ayres is a Hallmark heartthrob, most recently starring in Hallmark+‘s When Calls the Heart prequel series Hope Valley: 1874, which landed a Season 2 renewal. Outside of Hallmark, he has worked on shows like Smallville, Saving Hope, and Suits.