• “Drop Dead”

  

  Rodrigo welcomes fans into this the world of You Seem Pretty Sad for a Girl So In Love perfectly with “Drop Dead.” Not only does it open the album, it’s the first single the singer dropped from the album earlier this year.

  Sonically, “Drop Dead” encapsulates the album’s essence perfectly — it’s technically a love song and arguable one of the most optimistic tracks. However, even in the early stages of the album, and relationship, there’s an undercurrent of melancholy. It’s a clear foreshadowing to where both are going.

  This one’s already been deeply dissected, so onto the next one. – N.F.

• “Stupid Song”

  

  “I want you more than any stupid song could ever say” just might be the catchiest lyric on You Seem Pretty Sad for a Girl So In Love. The album’s second track finds Rodrigo doing one of the most relatable experiences for a 20-something woman: yearning.

  There’s plenty to love about “Stupid Song,” which the singer released a music video for when the album dropped, but the song’s bridge shines brightest: “It’s a thing that I can’t ignore / Tell your friends that you’re mine, I’m yours / With a hand on my heart, I swore / Nobody’s wanted somebody more.”

  The song’s dreamy and lovesick, and it’s poised to be her next big hit. – N.F.

• “Honeybee”

  

  Knowing where this album is headed, “Honeybee” feels less like a sweet and loving track, and more like a punch to the gut moment of foreshadowing. In the album’s third track, Rodrigo leans into the love she’s feeling (“And it’s too hard to describe this / In a way that feels honest / But even when I’m quiet / I love you, baby”) and hope to keep.

  If she was only just leaning into the love, it might not feel so devastating. But knowing this is an album about the life cycle of an eventual ended relationship makes the rest of the chorus hit a bit different. “And I hope I never see what your face looks like going / A face I swear that I could spend my whole life knowing,” she sings. “Herе’s to hoping.” – N.F.

• “Maggots for Brains”

  

  Rodrigo’s fourth track on You Seem Pretty Sad for a Girl So In Love, “Maggots for Brains,” goes all in on synth goodness. The track pinpoints the moments the relationship begins to unravel.

  The singer croons about how she’s lifeless without her lover as she explains in her chorus: “I’m a zombie in my body, I’m a train off of the track / I feel dirty, I feel rotten, and the colors are all flat / I’m a sad shell of a woman and I’ve got maggots for brains.”

  She’s also saying the inside thoughts out loud — I guess she can blame it on the maggots — in a refreshingly catchy way. “Sometimes, at a low point, I even wish for a tragedy,” she sings on second verse. “‘Cause I know hе’d come over and take rеal good care of me.” – N.F.

• “U + Me = <3”

  

  She’s in love, ladies and gentlemen. On sweet “U + Me = <3,” Rodrigo is ignoring the advice of her friends to dive headfirst into this new love: “All of my girlfriends roll their eyes / And tell me to take it slow this time.”

  Throughout the song, the pop star sings about wounds healing, winning over her lover’s sister with her “cynical humor and yacht rock music taste” and how much she likes him better than all her ex-boyfriends. It’s catchy, sonically pleasing and serves as the love song the elders can shake their fist at in the name of the nativity of young love.

  I mean, they might not be wrong. “They say modern love’s a cruel endeavor,” she sings on the last pre-chorus. “And to that I say, ‘Fuck it, whatever.’” – N.F.

• “My Way”

  

  On “My Way,” Rodrigo channels the most familiar sound to date, delivering one of the few tracks that would’ve felt at home on Guts. The song is crafted through the perspective of someone who’s experienced more of life but remains equally scorned.

  She sings about another woman not respecting her relationship and being unable to be affected by it: “It’s a little hard to stomach all your amateur moves / You know he’s with me, like obviously / But you linger in the air just like a bad perfume.”

  The second verse is where her jealousy comes through, along with realization that he might not be so innocent — why does she have his clothes exactly? “Man, I wonder what you think is gonna go down / You send him another poem and think that hе’ll let me go,” she sings. “Or maybe you’rе just tryna get me riled up now / You’re posting another pic in clothes that I know are his.” – N.F.

• “Purple”

  

  “Purple” starts off capturing the beauty in the subtle, everyday changes that come with a relationship, as Rodrigo croons about a tooth brush and pair of shoes that now “come in doubles,” and how she and her partner innocently fight about who they should go on couples dates with. 

  “I melt with you / your red and my blue/ now I see the world in purple,” Rodrigo sweetly sings over a synthy beat in the song’s chorus. 

  Rodrigo finishes the song with some dissonance, morphing the Modern English-coded metaphor of melting from a rose-colored idea into a more slogging, depressing feeling. “Melt with you till it all turns sad,” Rodrigo sings, as the song seems to melt away too. – E.M.

• “The Cure”

  

  Rodrigo’s third album doesn’t have a title track, but “The Cure,” — the album’s second single — sums up what You Seem Pretty Sad for a Girl So In Love is all about. 

  Love, Rodrigo thought, would be the antidote for for the negativity in her life such as jealousy or depression, but unfortunately, “it don’t matter how your love feels anymore” because “it’ll never be the cure.” – E.M.

• “Begged”

  

  The best love is the kind we don’t have to ask for — something Rodrigo captures with painful clarity on “Begged,” as she sings of trying to make the pain of not receiving the same love she gives, all while trying to accept and be grateful for the love has gotten. Yet, it’s clear that it’s not enough. 

  “So I’m patient / you’re learning / pretend it’s not hurting,” Rodrigo sings, as if to bargain with herself over feeling like something is missing. “They say it’s a virtue to not let good love slip away / So I’m cool and forgiving / I’ll take what you’re giving / But nothing’s quite enough when I know that to get it I begged.” – E.M.

• “What’s Wrong With Me”

  

  Rodrigo fans have been longing for a collaboration with The Cure’s Robert Smith ever since the duo played together at Glastonbury last year. That has finally come to fruition on “What’s Wrong With Me,” a catchy ‘80s goth-influenced bop that leans into that classic trope of the infectious, near-sickening feelings that come with heartbreak and a breakup on the horizon. 

  “Went to the doctor and she said I was fine / but every movie that I see makes me cry,” Rodrigo and Smith sing together at the beginning of the chorus. “My head is spinning and my stomach is sick / say I’m in love so it’s hard to admit / I can’t eat, I can’t sleep / I think you’re what’s wrong with me.” – E.M.

• “Less”

  

  If “I Think You’re What’s Wrong With Me” captures Rodrigo’s realization and acceptance that a relationship is the root of her anxieties, “Less” is that definitive, uncomfortable conversation with her romantic partner where they confront what’s amiss. 

  “You say you can’t stand to watch me cry a minute more,” Rodrigo sings. “So you do the noble thing and open up the door / If loving me means letting go and wishing me the best / Then I guess I wish you loved me less.”

  From there, Olivia and her partner do what so many couples not ready to call it quits do: they try to find that original spark. Unfortunately, that doesn’t work. “We tried to recreate our first date / but we didn’t laugh much this time,” she sings. “Our trip to Big Sur / Only Confirmed / This isn’t what it should feel like.”

  By the time the song’s done, the relationship has also ended.

  “If loving me means saying ‘babe, I think this is the end,’” Rodrigo sings, “Well I guess I wish you loved me less.” – E.M.

• “Expectations”

  

  After her breakup, Rodrigo ventures into the disappointing dating pool of Los Angeles. 

  “Took a couple months / but now I am secure / I am so evolved / now I ask for more and more,” Rodrigo says in the pre-chorus verse. 

  As she further stipulates during the chorus: “Gave my heart with zero stipulations / Now I take careful consideration… past mistakes are just new information / These days I’ve got expectations.”

  “Expectations” also has the album’s funniest lyric as she coyly jokes, “I don’t think my future husband’s at this bar in Silverlake.”

  All too relatable. – E.M.

• “Cigarette Smoke”

  

  The final track on the album concludes Rodrigo’s new era with some brutal honesty. 

  “I regret you and what I let slide,” Rodrigo says, a painful statement that declares that once-loving relationship as a mistake.

  “Tell me something honest so the memories turn dark,” Rodrigo says during the chorus, seeking to throw away any rose-colored tinting that me be left of that relationship. 

  “Go dark,” Rodrigo sings in a fading mumble in the final verse as the album comes to its close. – E.M.

THR Newsletters

Sign up for THR news straight to your inbox every day