Dan Levy's follow-up to Schitt's Creek teams him with I Love LA creator Rachel Sennott for a comedy that, in the best tradition of crime shows, starts small and gets absolutely ridonculous. Laurie Metcalf stars as mom and matriarch Linda alongside Dan Levy's closeted gay minister Nicky and Taylor Ortega's chaos-magnet Morgan. Linda demands that the two of them get a piece of jewelry for their dying grandmother's last birthday, leading to a tiny bit of theft that finds them in debt to the mob. Not content to put the family through the wringer just once, Netflix has renewed it for a second season. In the meantime, enjoy these other crime comedies that try and mostly fail to keep things in the family.

Good Girls (2018 – 2021)

Beth, Ruby and Annie (Christina Hendricks, Retta, and Mae Whitman, respectively) are three moms in suburban Michigan, and they are all having serious money troubles. They're not exactly criminal masterminds, so they concoct a scheme to rob the local grocery store to solve them—a store that just happens to be serve as a front for a money-laundering operation. They make off with $500,000—but the gang leader whose money they unknowingly stole wants it back. Oh, and the store manager spotted one of their distinctive tattoos and is threatening blackmail. It's definitely not a sitcom, but it's a solid comedy-drama with a talented cast of characters who keep finding themselves in deeper and deeper trouble over the course of four seasons. Stream Good Girls on Netflix.

Deli Boys (2025 – )

Pakistani-American journalist and producer Abdullah Saeed has long been celebrated for his investigative reporting and his Vice documentaries, many of them dealing with the impacts of cannabis laws. That experience lends a unique verisimilitude to this comedy series following two brothers—hardworking Mir (Asif Ali) and hard partying Raj (Saagar Shaikh)—who, after the death of their wealthy father, learn that the bulk of their family's money comes not from the public-facing chain of delis, but from the illegal drug operation running behind the scenes. It's fast-paced and frequently very fun, and plays with the notion that the only way to make it in modern America is to live some kind of double life. Stream Deli Boys on Hulu.

Search Party (2016 – 2022)

Alia Shawkat stars here as Dory Sief, an aimless millennial who decides, after seeing a missing-person poster for a college acquaintance, that she's going to make it her purpose to track down Chantal (Clare McNulty) with the extremely begrudging support of her friends. The show shifts focus from season to season, but it's really in the second that the similarities to Big Mistakes become most clear: While initially a darkly comic take on a Nancy Drew-style mystery, the show later finds the gang desperate to cover up a mostly unintentional murder. It's a funny, smart, and impressively weird oddity of a show. Stream Search Party on Netflix.

How to Get to Heaven From Belfast (2026 – )

How to Get to Heaven comes from Irish playwright and Derry Girls creator Lisa McGee, though that earlier and justifiably beloved show will only moderately prepare you for the latest. Three high school friends from Belfast reunite after learning that their fourth bestie has died unexpectedly—except that maybe she didn't, a mixed blessing given that they all have life-ruining secrets that they were hoping to bury. Now they're off to investigate the mystery of the maybe-murder, and find themselves in way over their heads and in a complex web of lies, secrets, and old vendettas. The tone is all over the place in a way that somehow works, and the show has a beating heart beneath the absolute chaos. Stream How to Get to Heaven From Belfast on Netflix.

Vincenzo (2021)

Vincenzo reads like a typical crime drama with just a bit of a twist: Song Joong-ki plays Park Joo-hyung AKA Vincenzo Cassano, Korean by birth but later adopted by an Italian family; as an adult he becomes a lawyer and Mafia consigliere. When the head of the Cassano Family dies, the Don's biological son looks to clean house, forcing Vincenzo to flee to Korea to claim a large cache of money he'd stashed. This is when it gets weirder and more interesting: The money's hidden under a commercial building full of weird and quirky tenants, and circumstances soon put Vincenzo at odds with the pharmaceutical conglomerate that has its eyes on the complex. What started as an unconventional mob story becomes a story about a guy using his mafia skills (the show doesn't shy away from violence) to battle capitalism on behalf of some charmingly goofy new friends. Stream Vincenzo on Netflix.

Barry (2018 – 2023)

Bill Hader won a couple of Emmys for his performance as Barry Berkman, a depressed and anxious hitman who discovers a love of acting that leads him to look for a life beyond killing people, even though he's rather good at it, and keeps getting drawn back in. Barry's mentor and father figure in his quest to rebuild his life on the stage is the wildly eccentric Gene Cousineau (Henry Winkler, who also won an Emmy here), who's entirely supportive of Barry—until he learns of his protégé's double life. Stream Barry on HBO Max.

Bad Sisters (2022 – 2024)

A pitch-dark and pitch-perfect comedy, the Irish import Bad Sisters picked up several well-deserved Emmy nominations in its first year. Writer and co-creator Sharon Horgan leads the cast as Eva Garvey, oldest of five sisters, including Grace (Anne-Marie Duff), who's married to John Paul, an abusive and isolating husband. When the dude winds up dead under rather suspicious circumstances, down-on-his-luck insurance investigator Tom (Brian Gleeson) starts poking his nose into things. We know the sisters definitely wanted John Paul dead, but did they actually do the deed? Tom's family business will go under if he has to pay out on the life insurance policy, so he's very motivated to pin the (potential) crime on at least one of the women. Stream Bad Sisters on Apple TV.

The Gentlemen (2024 – )

This is very much a Guy Ritchie show inspired by a Guy Ritchie film—which ought to tell you all you need to know about the vibe (polished, snarky, and ultra-violent). Theo James plays army officer and Eddie Horniman (I believe I mentioned Guy Ritchie?), heir to the Horniman estate (there it is again) who, upon the death of his father, is named the Duke of Halstead. He learns that dad was tied to various criminal enterprises, and that his scouse brother is millions of pounds in debt to a drug dealer. What else is the dapper, military-trained Duke to do but learn to navigate the violent underworld while looking cool? Stream The Gentlemen on Netflix.

The Sticky (2024)

Though it's tempting to find questionable taste in setting a caper show in Quebec and then having it involve maple syrup, The Sticky is loosely based on The Great Canadian Maple Syrup Heist—a real thing that happened in 2012. Margo Martindale (Justified) plays Ruth Landry, a maple syrup farmer struggling since her husband's incapacitation and running up against a greedy businessman trying to buy her land out from under her. She meets dopey security guard Remy Bouchard (Guillaume Cyr), who's been stealing a barrel or two at a time from the warehouse where he works, and then mobster Mike Byrne (Chris Diamontopoulos) who, she realizes, could provide the muscle needed for a heist. In the best tradition of something like Fargo, the foolproof plan to steal a bunch of syrup gets well out of hand, very quickly. The show ends on a bit of a cliffhanger, but there's still a relatively complete story in its single season. Stream The Sticky on Prime Video.

The Brothers Sun (2024)

A fun action-comedy and member of the Netflix one-season-and-done club, The Brothers Sun stars Oscar-winner Michelle Yeoh as Eileen Sun, the exiled matriarch of a family of Taiwanese gangsters. She'd come to Los Angeles years before, taking a son, Bruce (Sam Song Li), who grew up knowing little of his origins and has few ambitions beyond becoming great at improv comedy. An assassination attempt sends his older brother to L.A., drawing Eileen and Bruce back into the criminal fold, with rival factions coming at them from every side. Stream The Brothers Sun on Netflix.