When it comes to setting up your WordPress ecommerce business site, choosing the right platform is a critical first step. This decision impacts everything for your business, from costs and scalability to daily management. It’s important to do the research upfront so you can make the right choice.

Two of the top ecommerce options to consider are WooCommerce and BigCommerce. WooCommerce is a self-hosted, open-source platform offering a great deal of flexibility. BigCommerce is a Software as a Service (SaaS) platform with strong scalability and many out-of-the-box features.

Choosing the best platform is subjective and really depends on your particular ecommerce needs. This article will provide a comprehensive and neutral comparison of WooCommerce vs. BigCommerce, analyzing key factors including ownership, ease of use, cost structure, and scalability to help you choose the ideal ecommerce platform for your business.

WooCommerce: Self-Hosted with Impressive Flexibility

WooCommerce is a free, open-source plugin for WordPress that converts your website into an online store. It is self-hosted, so the user controls the hosting environment and the code it runs on.

WooCommerce Key Strengths

• Flexibility and Customization: Provides limitless customization opportunities thanks to the vast WordPress and plugin ecosystem. Since you own the code, you can develop it as you like.
• Content Marketing Power: Seamless integration with WordPress makes it a good fit for content-driven stores and SEO.
• Cost Structure: Offers low-entry cost (a free plugin) with associated costs for hosting, domains, and premium extensions.
• Ownership: Full control of the data and the environment is maintained by the site owner.

Ideal WooCommerce User Types

• Businesses with existing WordPress websites or strong content strategies
• Developers and technically proficient users who require deep customization
• Users who prioritize full ownership and code control

BigCommerce: Hosted SaaS with Effective Scalability

BigCommerce is a SaaS platform that is fully hosted and managed for you. As a hosted solution, BigCommerce handles the security, performance, and updates automatically.

BigCommerce Key Strengths

• Simplicity and Ease of Use: Built to be easy and user-friendly with a centralized, intuitive dashboard to manage everything.
• Built-In Scalability: Excellent performance and security out-of-the-box, and engineered to handle massive traffic spikes without having to manually scale.
• Core Features: Robust native features including multi-channel sales, multi-currency, and checkout optimization.
• “Headless” Ready: Offers a strong API for decoupled builds and enterprise-level integrations.

Ideal BigCommerce User Types

• Businesses that prioritize simplicity, security, and a hands-off approach to technical management
• High-growth, high-volume, and enterprise-level stores that need guaranteed stability
• Non-technical users who want built-in compliance and support.

WooCommerce vs. BigCommerce: Direct Comparison

A direct comparison between these two platforms can help clarify which is the better fit for your business’ needs.

Cost Structure and Ownership

• WooCommerce: Variable cost, with hosting being a primary factor. Also, you own your own data.
• BigCommerce: Predictable monthly SaaS subscription fee. There are limits on annual sales volume that, if they are overrun, lead to required plan upgrades. Also, a third-party owns your core platform and code.

Technical Management and Maintenance

• WooCommerce: Site owners have high involvement in managing the ecommerce infrastructure including responsibility for updates, security, caching, and hosting. Also, it works best when paired with a managed hosting provider.
• BigCommerce: Site owners have low involvement in managing the ecommerce infrastructure as the provider handles all security, server maintenance, and core updates. It is very much a hands-off experience for the site owner.

Customizations and Integrations

• WooCommerce: Offers unlimited custom code and plugins. Site owners have access to the largest ecosystem of extensions to pull from.
• BigCommerce: Offers customization via themes, apps, and APIs. The platform offers excellent native features, but the app marketplace is smaller than what WordPress offers.

Scalability and Performance

• WooCommerce: Highly scalable, but the performance depends entirely on the site owner’s managed hosting budget and the provider’s optimization expertise.
• BigCommerce: Scales automatically and instantly with traffic upticks. It also offers a high uptime guarantee regardless of the ecommerce store size.

Security and Compliance

• WooCommerce: Requires hands-on management of security plugins, backups, and patching.
• BigCommerce: Platform-level security management simplifies PCI compliance and reduces manual oversight.

Choosing the Right Ecommerce Platform

In doing your research on the best platform for your ecommerce business, there are many factors to consider. WooCommerce offers a great deal of control and customizability, making it a good fit for hands-on users or developers. BigCommerce offers guaranteed stability and ease of management, making it a strong option for high-growth, non-technical businesses. 

In making your decision, you need to determine which one aligns best to your technical resources, how much budget you have for development vs. subscription fees, and whether you need greater flexibility (WooCommerce) or trusted reliability (BigCommerce).

Take the time to figure out your business priorities and confirm that the platform you’re considering best aligns with them before you commit to either ecommerce platform.

Pressable: Your WooCommerce Hosting Provider

If you’re considering the WooCommerce platform, know that Pressable is optimized to support WooCommerce stores on WordPress, providing a hosting foundation that delivers unmatched speed, security, and reliability. Your site’s page loads are optimized to deliver an efficient and reliable experience to your visitors. We give you the technical confidence you need to focus your attention on integrating useful plugins that help you improve your overall ecommerce user experience.

Pressable—part of the Automattic family that also includes WordPress.com, WordPress VIP, and WooCommerce—is staffed by experts with the skills and knowledge to effectively manage your WordPress site. If you’re thinking about switching to managed WordPress hosting, schedule a demo to see how Pressable can support your continued optimization and growth.

Read More Articles in Hosting Essentials