View PDF HTML (experimental)

Abstract:Standard MCMC diagnostics ($\hat{R}$, effective sample size, divergence counts) detect whether a chain has mixed, but not why it has not. We ask whether the centring/non-centring obstruction in hierarchical models has a geometric cause beyond the metric. The joint parameter space is a fiber bundle (hyperparameters the base, group-level parameters the fibers), and the Fisher information metric induces an Ehresmann connection $A = -G_{FF}^{-1}G_{BF}$; the natural hypothesis is that the obstruction is its curvature, felt by the sampler as holonomy. We prove this false. The connection is flat for any smooth hierarchical posterior, not only the Gaussian case, because its horizontal leaves are the level sets of the fiber score $\partial_\alpha \log p$: there is no geometric obstruction above the metric. What remains is statistical, not geometric, and the flat connection identifies it as a single quantity: the conditional dependence of fiber on base, governed per group by the prior fraction $\pi_j$, the classical pooling factor. From it the framework recovers the established picture, that prior-dominated groups mix slowly and that the optimal per-group non-centring weight follows in closed form, and a simulation study separates this base-fiber coupling from the funnel, a distinct base-space pathology, by their opposite dependence on the hierarchical variance. A direct attribution test confirms that NUTS does not transport the fiber: the chain-level footprint is excess conditional autocorrelation in prior-dominated groups, exactly as $\pi_j$ predicts. Genuine, even rotational, curvature does appear, but only for connections built from a sampler's working metric (a fixed mass matrix), where holonomy re-enters as an algorithmic rather than geometric phenomenon. The prior-fraction diagnostic is distributed as the R package fibr, with the geometric methods as accompanying reproduction code.

Submission history

From: Aidan Bindoff [view email]
[v1] Wed, 17 Jun 2026 23:38:58 UTC (1,010 KB)