We consider the equal sum partition problem, motivated by distance magic graph labeling: Given $n,k \in \N$ such that $k\, | \sum_{i=1}^ni$ and a partition $p_1+\cdots+p_k=n$, when is it possible to find a partition of the set $\{1,2,\ldots,n\}$ into $k$ subsets of sizes $p_1,\dots,p_k$, such that the element sum in each subset is the same? A known necessary condition is the \emph{slack condition}, requiring that for all $j$, placing the largest possible elements in the $j$ smallest sets yields a total sum that is at least what is needed. However, this condition is not sufficient, and known counterexamples exist. This work clarifies the boundary between solvable and unsolvable instances of the problem. We extend the list of unsolvable problem instances satisfying the slack condition by exhibiting infinite families where the $n/k$ ratio is any rational number in the interval $(2,\frac{24}{7})$, and a new criterion for unsolvability. Furthermore, we show that the slack condition is natural, as it is both necessary and sufficient for the fractional relaxation of the problem. Based on this result, we prove that the problem is solvable for the class of linear partitions, where $k$ is fixed, $p_1,\ldots,p_k$ grow linearly with $n$, and where the slack condition holds in a strong sense. We do this by applying a randomized rounding algorithm to a solution of the fractional relaxation of the problem and proving that the algorithm has an exponentially small failure probability.